Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Windows is not painful and sluggish compared to Linux GUIs. It's on par. If your GUI is sluggish it's because you're letting stuff like letting crappy antivirus and malware detection run in the background or you have an underpowered machine for what windows needs. Sure Xubuntu will trash Windows on an old P4 however on modern hardware they'll be fairly equivalent with windows having a slight edge due to better video acceleration. I use both daily and they're both responsive environments.


> Windows is not painful and sluggish compared to Linux GUIs. It's on par.

30% longer compile times than on Linux on the same hardware.

Using git takes time compared to being instantaneous.

Running "hello world" written in .Net takes 3-5 seconds compared to <<1 second on Linux on the same hardware.

> If your GUI is sluggish it's because you're letting stuff like letting crappy antivirus and malware detection run in the background or you have an underpowered machine for what windows needs.

As I mentioned above, Linux is amazingly much faster on the same hardware! And brand new 2018/2019 hardware at that when I measured last time.

That said antivirus is a real problem. Part of the problem is that mandatory Windows OS often signals sysadmins that doesn't care, so you often get tragically bad antivirus, possibly misconfigured at that.


I/O on Windows is definitively slower point and it affects git performance but OP says about GUI.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18783525




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: