Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why do anything with them?


Because if you don't, the seasons and the months will drift out of sync with each other. And you don't even get the benefits of a lunar calendar as a tradeoff, because your weeks are shorter than 1/4 of a lunar month, and your months are two days longer than a lunar month.


> Because if you don't, the seasons and the months will drift out of sync with each other.

And?

> And you don't even get the benefits of a lunar calendar as a tradeoff

What are the benefits of a lunar calendar? And it's not like our 7-day week actually stays in sync with the moon, it's just approximately the same length.


> And?

People like predictability for planning things like travel, holidays, school, etc.


You can't just disappear them into the void. The length of a year is not something we can control.


We've changed the length of a year several times in history, what's one more?


The length of a year is determined by the earth's orbit around the sun. Sure, you can make a calendar that isn't actually a year long, and then correct the errors that accumulate every once in a while, either by inserting a few months every few hundred years, or by adding a leap day every 4 years, but why would you intentionally make a calendar that isn't a year long? Leap days are unavoidable, but seasons drifting out-of-sync are not.


We can define a year however we want, but then planet Earth will answer "Ok, then my new orbit is 0.95434 years".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: