Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Organizing still requires access to ground truth information. It's not enough for people to be organized. They do need to be organized around actual good ideas which requires information.

Organizing without journalism is just religious evangelism and mob justice.



No, this still doesn't matter. Just still waste of time of time caring about what journalists think over activating the local community into your cause.

Go read "No Shortcuts" by Jane McAlevey to understand what effective organizing is.


I don't think you're hearing me.

You are presuming that one has a cause and that that cause is correct.

But where does that presumption come from? In order to be worth supporting, a cause does actually need to be based in reality. And you can't get that without journalism.

Should I join a cause that wants to outlaw popsicle sticks? Raise taxes on birdwatchers? Require owners of unicycles to register them? How does someone figure out what's a useful cause without actual information?


There's no point in hearing you because you're still espousing ineffective things. You do you, I know what works because I've been doing it for 5 years. The people that taught me were doing it effectively for 40 years. It's not complicated or hard, you just have to you know... actually organize with the appropriate power players.

I can see why advocacy is appealing to you though because you aren't sacrificing anything and allows oneself to be lazy rather than effective.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: